Lowering Blood Pressure By Cutting Back On Salt – Is It Based On Sound Science

What’s the very first thing that involves thoughts when you concentrate on recommendation for decreasing blood strain?

It’s extremely prone to be the fixed chorus to limit salt consumption. It is hardly stunning; have a look at any well being or medical web site and the primary tip you are prone to see for decreasing blood pressure monitors is to “in the reduction of on salt”. We have been lectured about this for thus lengthy, many years the truth is, that salt (sodium) has turn into inextricably linked to hypertension (hypertension).

However is it true? Or may or not it’s that like many issues that we have heard time and again, it is only a huge fats delusion? In different phrases…

Will slicing your salt consumption actually assist in decreasing blood strain?

That is an awesome query that many individuals (once they cease and give it some thought) wish to have answered: I imply, for instance you comply with a reasonably good weight-reduction plan… do it is advisable to fear about salt?

You see, this entire salt factor has been haunting us since again within the 1970’s, when Lewis Dahl did a research exhibiting that larger salt consumption raised the blood strain of rats in a lab. After all unhealthy information will get consideration and many individuals took the conclusions of that research at face worth and ran with them. However there have been severe flaws within the research that had been broadly missed within the zeal to establish a wrongdoer for hypertension.

Initially, the rats had been fed an quantity of salt equal to a human consumption of 5 hundred GRAMS day by day. In contrast, the typical human salt consumption is round 2500 mg (2.5 grams) per day.

And this wasn’t the one drawback with Dahl’s research. Let’s simply say it was principally flimsy. However regardless of this…

U.S. Surgeon Basic hyperlinks salt/sodium to hypertension…

In 1979 the U.S. Surgeon Basic’s annual report included a blanket assertion about salt and it is hyperlink to hypertension, however even this report was a bit iffy on particulars. This is what it stated:


Excessive dietary salt consumption could produce hypertension, significantly in inclined folks… Unequivocally, research in genetically predisposed animals present a cause-effect relationship between excessive salt consumption and elevated blood strain. Research in man additionally recommend such a relationship and present, too, that when hypertension is current controlling salt consumption will help fight it.


Not the sturdiest of arguments, and while you perceive that the “research in genetically predisposed animals” was primarily based largely on Dahl’s research, it kind of makes you query the phrase “unequivocally”, does it not?

The shaky edifice that salt prohibition was constructed on continued to rise, with well being professionals at all times “erring on the facet of warning” and most people keen to simply accept their edicts with out studying the effective print behind them. And so it was that we got here to imagine that top salt/sodium consumption was a serious explanation for hypertension.

Reduce on salt for decrease blood strain: the proof mounts (or does it?)…

The following battle within the battle in opposition to salt was set to kick off. In 1988 researchers got down to show Dahl’s “salt speculation” with the most important research ever on the correlation between salt consumption and hypertension. This research noticed 52 inhabitants teams unfold over 32 international locations worldwide and took 4 years to finish.

However as soon as once more, the proof that got here again was lower than “unequivocal”. It did conclude that a part of the Dahl salt speculation was right, that “there’s a regular constructive correlation between salt (sodium) consumption and imply systolic blood strain (MSBP). Particularly, that MSBP drops 1-6 mm HG for 100 mmol discount in day by day sodium consumption”.*

*British Medical Journal INTERSALT: a world research of electrolyte excretion and blood strain: outcomes for twenty-four hour urinary sodium and potassium excretion, INTERSALT Cooperative Analysis Group, BMJ, 1988)

However, once more, there’s an issue with these findings: Of the fifty-two social teams studied, 4 had been primitive societies whose salt consumption and blood strain had been each extraordinarily low. WITH these 4 teams included within the knowledge there was a constructive relationship between salt and blood strain. However WITHOUT these 4 teams, knowledge for the opposite forty-eight teams confirmed no relationship by any means.

There’s extra: the conclusions fail to take into consideration the truth that the 4 primitive societies skilled much less stress, consumed a low fats/excessive fiber weight-reduction plan, had far much less weight problems and consumed a lot fewer processed meals. All or any of those components may very nicely have influenced the group’s blood strain and thus the research’s findings.

Maybe essentially the most vital discovering of all was that, trying particularly on the different forty-eight teams revealed a small unfavourable relationship: when sodium intakes elevated, strain ranges went down!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *